Comparison between proton and iron results

ECUTS: 1 TeV, MinEnergy: 100 GeV

Red: proton
Blue: iron

Results

primary particle energy Dot line: without cut normal line: with DOM#>80

primary particle energy weighted by the CR flux Dot line: without cut normal line: with DOM#>80

cos(zenith angle) of the primary particle. Dot line represents events whose hit DOM number above 80. (high energy events)	cos(zenith angle) of the primary particle weighted by hte CR flux. Dot line represents events whose hit DOM number above 80. (high energy events)	azimuth angle of the primary particle.
cos(zenith angle) of the primary particle Vs the energy. larger dots represents events whose hit DOM number above 80. (high energy events)
Multiplicity of muons Dot line: without cut normal line: with DOM#>80	Multiplicity Vs primary energy
cos(Zenith angle) Vs Multiplicity of muons
Energy distribution at IceCube detector (in ice) Dot line: without cut normal line: with DOM#>80	Energy distribution at IceCube detector (in ice) weighted by the CR flux Dot line: without cut normal line: with DOM#>80
Energy in ice Vs primary energy	Energy in ice Vs primary energy Iron leands to ~factor 2 more muon bundle energy	cos(zenith angle) Vs energy in ice
Energy distribution at surface Dot line: without cut normal line: with DOM#>80	Energy distribution at surface weighted by the CR flux Dot line: without cut normal line: with DOM#>80
Energy at surface Vs primary energy	Energy at surface Vs primary energy Iron leands to ~factor 2 more muon bundle energy
cos(zenith angle) Vs energy at surface
Energy at surface Vs energy in ice There is a constant energy loss during the propagation from surface to the detector (~log10(0.2)~30%)
Npe distribution at IceCube detector (in ice) ECUTS thres 1 TeV Dot line: without cut normal line: with DOM#>80	Npe distribution at IceCube detector (in ice) ECUTS thres 1 TeV Dot line: without cut normal line: with DOM#>80
Npe Vs in-ice bundle energy	Cos(zenith angle) Vs Npe in ice

---

Comaprison with observational data

Npe distribution (corresponding to ~62 days) Corsika data is much less than observed. data: black MC: red